The Islamic Revolution Approach

The Islamic Revolution Approach

The effects of the principle of innocence on the formulation of citizenship rights in Iran's related laws: a political reading

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor of Jurisprudence and Law Department, Yasouj Branch, Islamic Azad University, Yasouj, Iran
2 PhD student of Fiqh and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Zahedan Islamic Azad University
3 Associate Professor of Fiqh and Fundamentals of Islamic Law Education Department, Payam Noor University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
the relationship between citizens and the state has long been a concern for thinkers in the fields of public law and political philosophy. These thinkers have sought mechanisms to regulate the relationship between society and government in a way that preserves citizens' rights while ensuring that the government can effectively manage society. In this context, Islamic thinkers in the modern era have always contemplated how to leverage Islamic intellectual and civilizational capacities to address the challenges of the modern world. This article focuses on the effects of the principle of presumption of innocence on the codification of citizens' rights in Iranian law. The main hypothesis is that the principle of presumption of innocence, as a foundational principle in Shia jurisprudence, possesses significant potential for application in public law and for regulating the relationship between citizens and the state, beyond its role in private law. Research findings indicate that citizens' relations and the rights stemming from them, which are among the main political issues in the modern era, can be regulated through legislative mechanisms, utilizing the principle of presumption of innocence and its legal implications. The research employs a descriptive-analytical methodology, with data collected through library research.
 
Introduction
The concept of citizenship should be analyzed within the broader context of social rights and human rights. This analysis must focus on three major issues: the nature of citizenship, the relationship of citizenship with other key social institutions, and the historical processes that have given rise to and expanded citizenship. Citizenship is fundamentally a modern concept, emerging with modernity and the political agency of individuals, allowing citizens to participate in public affairs. All countries moving towards political modernity, including Iran, have inevitably engaged with citizens' rights. However, some argue that citizenship in the Iranian legal system is plagued by theoretical confusion. Thus, this article examines the effects of the principle of presumption of innocence on the codification of citizens' rights in Iranian law.
Materials & Methods
A citizen is a member of a political community who possesses rights and duties associated with membership. The concept of citizenship is intertwined with the public sphere. For Hannah Arendt, the public sphere encompasses two distinct yet interdependent dimensions: the space of appearance, which is a realm of political freedom and equality created through the collective actions of citizens mediated by discourse and persuasion; and the common world, a shared and public space consisting of artifacts, institutions, and human environments. Citizenship manifests itself in these two dimensions. Today, two major challenges confront citizenship theory: the plurality of political systems and globalization. The latter posits that citizens' rights are an extension of human rights. Therefore, by respecting citizens' rights, governments effectively adhere to human rights. The Islamic Republic of Iran must address citizens' rights in both dimensions: as a unique and specific system and as one existing in a globalized world.
 
Discussion & Results
Citizens' rights in Iran are rooted in religious texts, as citizenship in Islam is based on rights and obligations. Thus, attention to Islamic jurisprudential rules is essential. One of these jurisprudential principles, the principle of presumption of innocence, can serve as a foundation for establishing Islamic citizens' rights. According to this principle, where there is no religious obligation, individuals have the right to act freely. If we categorize citizens' rights into three types—civil rights, political rights, and social rights—we can derive all of them from the principle of presumption of innocence. Civil rights encompass the rights to own property and adhere to contracts, while political rights arise from the non-domination of individuals, allowing for freedom of choice.
 
Conclusion
Islamic civilization faces a complex situation, as it must contend with the demands of modernity while remaining faithful to its values and ideological frameworks. The status of citizens and citizens' rights is one of the challenges of this complex situation. To address this issue, Islamic jurisprudence can be utilized. The principle of presumption of innocence holds substantial potential for application in public law and for regulating the relationship between citizens and the state. This research reveals that citizens' rights consist of two fundamental pillars: one within civil rights, encompassing all areas outside the government, and the other within political rights, which include political activities. All these aspects can be inferred from the principle of presumption of innocence.
Keywords

  • Abedi Sarasia, Alireza (2017), "The Rule of Domination and Its Role in Correcting New Contracts (With Reference to the Thoughts of Imam Khomeini (PBUH))," Matin Journal, 19(75), 129-154. {in persian}
  • Alsan, Mostafa (2008), "Citizenship Rights from the Perspective of Global Citizenship Theory and Iran's Laws and Regulations," International Human Rights Law Review, 03(2), 3-20.
  • Ameli, Saeed Reza (2001), "The Interaction of Globalization, Citizenship, and Religion," Social Science Letter, No. 18, pp. 1-58.
  • Bashiriyeh, Hossein (2007), Reason in Politics, Tehran: Contemporary View Publishing.
  • Dantro, Maurizio Passerin (2012), Hannah Arendt: The Theory of Citizenship, translated by Abbas Shahrabi Farahani, Anthropology and Culture Website.
  • Douzinas, Costas (2017), Human Rights and Empire, translated by Ali Saberi Toulayi, Tehran: Tarjoman Publishing.
  • Eyvazi, Mohammad Rahim; Bab Gureh, Seyed Hosameddin (2012), "The Transformation of the Concept of Citizenship and the Emergence of Global Citizenship," Political Quarterly, 42(3), 187-205. {in persian}
  • Farzanepour, Hossein; Hamidi, Somayeh; and Nourmohammadi, Reyhaneh (2022), "Examining the Four-Decade Performance of the Islamic Republic of Iran in Realizing Citizenship Rights: Obstacles and Challenges," Islamic Revolution Approach, 16(60), 3-28. {in persian}
  • Firooz, Davood (2012), Jurisprudence and Politics in Contemporary Iran, Tehran: Nashr-e Ney. {in persian}
  • Hashemi Shahroudi, Seyed Mahmoud (2003), Jurisprudential Culture According to the School of Ahl al-Bayt (AS), Tehran: Institute of Islamic Jurisprudence Encyclopedia. {in persian}
  • Hekmatnia, Mahmoud (2004), "The Labor-Ownership Theory and Its Application in Intellectual Property," Comparative Law Scientific Semi-Annual Journal, 0(7), 151-182.
  • Javid, Mohammad Javad (2014), "Re-examining the Philosophical Foundations of Relativity Theory in Citizenship Rights," Islamic Law Quarterly, 11(42), 65-95.
  • Journal, No. 58, Spring 2007, pp. 153-172.
  • Kholousi, Mohammad Hossein (2017), "Explaining the Concept and Components of Citizenship in the Political Philosophy of Aristotle and Farabi," Fundamental Research in Human Sciences Quarterly, No. 6, Spring 2017, pp. 73-97.
  • Kymlicka, Will (2016), Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights, translated by Ebrahim Eskafi, Tehran: Shirazeh Ma Publishing. {in persian}
  • Locke, John (2017), Two Treatises of Government, translated by Hamid Azodanloo, Tehran: Nashr-e Ney. {in persian}
  • Loughlin, Martin (2012), The Foundations of Public Law, translated by Mohammad Rasekh, Tehran: Nashr-e Ney. {in persian}
  • Mahalati, Mohammad Soroush (2004), "The Principle of Non-Governance," Political Science Research Quarterly, 7(25 - Spring 2004), 63-72. {in persian}
  • Mirahmadi, Mansour (1998), "An Analysis of the Concept of Political Freedom," Political Science Quarterly, No. 22, Summer 1998. {in persian}
  • Mohaqeq Damad, Mostafa (1995), Rules of Jurisprudence (Civil Law Section), Tehran: SAMT Publications. {in persian}
  • Nikfar, Mohammad Reza (2010), Violence, Human Rights, Civil Society, Tehran: Tarh-e No Publishing. {in persian}
  • Nussbaum, Martha (2019), The Monarchy of Fear, translated by Hamed Ghadiri, Tehran: Tarjoman Publishing. {in persian}
  • Qureshi, Seyed Mehdi; Ebrahimi, Hojjatollah; and Ranjbar, Maqsood (2022), "Examining the Role of the Judiciary in Protecting Citizenship Rights in the Islamic Republic of Iran within the Framework of Good Governance," Islamic Revolution Approach, 16(58), 27-46. {in persian}
  • Sharbatiyan, Mohammad Hassan; Bokharaei, Ahmad; and Ahmadi, Azam (2015), "Sociological Analysis of Lifestyle and Tendency Towards Citizenship Rights (A Case Study of Payame Noor University Students in South Khorasan)," Applied Sociology, 26(4), 87-108. {in persian}
  • Spector, Céline (2003), Power and Sovereignty in the History of Western Thought, translated by Abbas Bagheri, Tehran: Nashr-e Ney.
  • Tabatabaei Motameni, Manouchehr (1991), Public Freedoms and Human Rights, Tehran: University of Tehran Press. {in persian}
  • Tabatabaei, Mohammad Hossein (1981), Al-Mizan Interpretation (Vol. 2), translated by a group of translators, Qom: Islamic Publications Office (affiliated with the Society of Seminary Teachers of Qom). {in persian}
  • Tahernia, Ahmad (2015), "The Origins and Essence of the Principle of Non-Governance in Shia Political Jurisprudence," Islamic Government, 20th Year, Winter 2015, No. 4 (Consecutive 78). {in persian}
  • Turner, Bryan (2007), "The Concept of Citizenship," translated by Javad Karzgari, Judiciary Law
  • Valavi, Saeed; Ahangaran, Mohammad Rasoul; and Aghaei Bejestani, Maryam (2020), "Islamic Citizenship Rights in the System of the Islamic Republic of Iran with an Emphasis on the Rule of Benevolence," Islamic Revolution Approach, 14(51), 3-44. {in persian}
  • Leydet، Dominique (2023)، "Citizenship"، The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2023 Edition)، Edward N. Zalta & Uri Nodelman (eds.)