The Islamic Revolution Approach

The Islamic Revolution Approach

Social Inequality and Crime in Iran: An Analysis Based on Gabriel Tarde’s Theory of Imitation

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD Candidate in Criminal Law and Criminology, UAE Branch, Islamic Azad University, Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Faculty of Administrative Sciences and Economics, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran (Corresponding Author)
3 Faculty Member, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.
Abstract
This study examines the relationship between social inequality and crime in Iran through the analytical framework of Gabriel Tarde’s theory of imitation. The central problem of the research is to explain how economic, educational, institutional, and symbolic inequalities contribute to the reproduction of criminal behavior through processes of social imitation and behavioral diffusion. The primary research question asks how mechanisms of imitation shape the expansion and persistence of criminal behavior within the context of social inequality in contemporary Iran. The study hypothesizes that the weakening of legitimate pathways for social mobility encourages the emergence of imitative criminal networks, thereby reinforcing deviant behavior and facilitating the social transmission of crime. The research adopts a qualitative design based on theoretical and documentary analysis, drawing upon Iranian and international scholarly literature, official statistical reports, criminological studies, and policy documents. The findings indicate that social inequality promotes criminal behavior by weakening cultural capital, undermining institutional trust, reinforcing peer-based criminal networks, and increasing the attractiveness of illegitimate status models. Rather than viewing crime solely as an economic response to deprivation, the study demonstrates that criminal behavior is reproduced through social learning, imitation, and network-based interactions. The research concludes that effective crime prevention policies should focus not only on reducing economic inequality but also on strengthening legitimate social mobility, rebuilding institutional trust, promoting positive social role models, and interrupting the mechanisms through which criminal behaviors are socially transmitted.

Introduction
Crime has become one of the most significant social challenges confronting contemporary societies, particularly those experiencing widening social and economic inequalities. Traditional criminological explanations have frequently emphasized poverty, unemployment, or individual characteristics as the primary causes of criminal behavior. However, these approaches often overlook the mechanisms through which criminal behavior spreads and becomes socially reproduced. In Iran, increasing income disparities, urban marginalization, unemployment, educational inequality, and declining social trust have intensified concerns regarding the growth and diversification of criminal activities. While previous Iranian studies have largely examined the statistical association between poverty and crime, comparatively little attention has been devoted to understanding how criminal behavior is transmitted through social relationships and networks. Gabriel Tarde's theory of imitation offers an alternative perspective by conceptualizing crime as a socially transmitted phenomenon rather than merely an individual response to deprivation. From this viewpoint, criminal behavior spreads through interpersonal interaction, social learning, symbolic influence, and network diffusion. This study therefore investigates how social inequality facilitates the formation of criminal networks through processes of imitation and examines the implications of this relationship for crime prevention and social policy in Iran.
Materials and Methods
This research employs a qualitative descriptive-analytical methodology grounded in theoretical and documentary analysis. The analytical framework is primarily based on Gabriel Tarde's theory of imitation, particularly his concepts of imitation, innovation, social diffusion, the laws of imitation, and relational social interaction. Documentary sources include Iranian and international criminological literature, official crime statistics, reports published by governmental institutions, international organizations, and peer-reviewed academic research addressing crime, inequality, urban marginalization, and social learning. The study synthesizes theoretical arguments with empirical evidence concerning economic inequality, educational disparities, symbolic deprivation, institutional weakness, peer influence, and media environments in order to explain the reproduction of criminal behavior in contemporary Iran. Rather than testing causal relationships statistically, the research seeks to construct an integrated theoretical explanation linking structural inequalities with network-based mechanisms of behavioral transmission.
Discussion
The findings suggest that social inequality creates favorable conditions for the emergence and reproduction of criminal behavior through interconnected processes of social imitation. Economic deprivation alone does not automatically generate crime; rather, inequality becomes criminogenic when legitimate opportunities for social mobility decline and alternative models of success become socially attractive. Tarde's theory demonstrates that criminal behavior spreads through interpersonal relationships, peer groups, neighborhoods, prisons, and increasingly through digital communication networks. In Iran, structural inequalities weaken institutional trust, reduce cultural capital, and limit educational opportunities, encouraging marginalized individuals to adopt behaviors observed within their immediate social environment. Symbolic inequality further reinforces this process by increasing the social appeal of illegitimate wealth and status. Criminal success may gradually acquire symbolic legitimacy within disadvantaged communities, encouraging imitation by younger generations. The analysis also indicates that prisons may unintentionally function as environments that reinforce criminal learning when rehabilitation and social reintegration mechanisms remain weak. Consequently, crime is better understood as a socially reproduced phenomenon sustained through networks of interaction rather than solely as the product of individual decision-making or material deprivation.
Results
The study concludes that the relationship between social inequality and crime in Iran extends beyond economic deprivation to encompass broader processes of social learning and behavioral diffusion. Economic, educational, institutional, and symbolic inequalities collectively weaken legitimate pathways of social advancement while strengthening the attractiveness of alternative criminal networks. Peer groups, urban marginalization, media exposure, and prison environments function as important channels through which criminal behaviors are transmitted and normalized. The findings further demonstrate that effective crime prevention requires interventions beyond conventional punitive measures. Policies aimed at reducing social inequality, expanding educational opportunities, strengthening institutional legitimacy, rebuilding social trust, improving post-release reintegration, and promoting legitimate models of social success are essential for interrupting the cycles of criminal imitation. Ultimately, Gabriel Tarde's theory provides a valuable theoretical framework for understanding how crime is reproduced within unequal societies and offers important insights for developing comprehensive social and criminal justice policies in Iran.
Keywords

1-                Barnes, Harry E. (1919), “The Philosophy of the State in the Writings of Gabriel Tarde,” Journal of The Philosophical Review, Vol. 28, No. 3, Pp. 248-279.
2-                Barry, Andrew. & Thrift, Nigel (2007), “Gabriel Tarde: imitation, invention and economy”, Journal of Economy and Society, Vol. 36, No.4: 509-525.
3-                Borch, Christian (2005), ”Urban Imitations: Tarde's Sociology Revisited”, Theory, Culture & Society, Vol. 22, No. 3: 81–100.
4-                Brighenti, Andrea Mubi (2010), “Tarde, Canetti, and Deleuze on crowds and packs”. Journal of Classical Sociology, Vol. 10. No. 4: 291-314.
5-                Cerulo, M. (2021). Gabriel Tarde. In The Emotions in the Classics of Sociology (pp. 39-53). Routledge.
6-                Cerulo, M. (2021). Gabriel Tarde. In The Emotions in the Classics of Sociology (pp. 39-53). Routledge.
7-                Gardhouse, A. K. (2025). Gabriel Tarde and the Relational Foundations of Agency (Doctoral dissertation).
8-                Gardhouse, A. K. (2025). Gabriel Tarde and the Relational Foundations of Agency (Doctoral dissertation).
9-                King, A. (2016). Gabriel Tarde and contemporary social theory. Sociological Theory, 34(1), 45-61.
10-              Marrero-Guillamón, Isaac (2013), “Actor-Network Theory, Gabriel Tarde and the Study of an Urban Social Movement: The Case of Can Ricart, Barcelona”, Journal of Qual Sociol, No. 36: 403–421.
11-              Nachtomy, Ohad (2007), Possibility, agency, and individuality in Leibnitz’s metaphysics. The Netherlands: Springer Press.    
12-              Niezen, Ronald (2014), “Gabriel Tarde's publics”. Journal of History of the Human Sciences”, Vol. 27. No.2:. 41–59.
13-              Papliloud, Christian (2004), “UNDERSTANDING INTERACTIVITY WITH GABRIEL TARDE”. Journal of Distinktion, No.9: 83-102.
14-              Renneville, M. (2018). Gabriel Tarde, the Swallow of French Criminology. The Anthem Companion to Gabriel Tarde, 103-118.
15-              Tarde, Gabriel (1903), The laws of imitation, (Elsie Clews Parsons Trans). New York: The Mershon Company Press.
16-              Tarde, Gabriel (2000), Social laws: An outline of sociology. (Howard C. Warren Trans). New York: Batoche Books Kitchener Press.
17-              Tarde, Gabriel (2012), Monadology and Sociology, (Theo Lorenc Edit. & Trans.). Melbourne: Re-press.
18-              Tonkonoff, S. (2014). Crime as social excess: Reconstructing Gabriel Tarde’s criminal sociology. History of the Human Sciences, 27(2), 60-74.
19-              United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC). (2021). Global study on homicide 2021. Vienna: UNODC.
20-              Walker Jr, B. D. (2022). Evaluating the Concepts of the Tarde Imitation Theory and Its Impact on Training Effectiveness for Law Enforcement in Times of Disaster.
21-              Walker Jr, B. D. (2022). Evaluating the Concepts of the Tarde Imitation Theory and Its Impact on Training Effectiveness for Law Enforcement in Times of Disaster.
 
{in persian}
Ahmadi, H., & Iman, M. (2005). Culture of poverty, marginalization, and tendencies toward delinquent behavior among marginalized youth in Dah-Piyaleh, Shiraz (2004). University of Isfahan Research Journal, 19, 99–118. {in persian}
Azarian Ghahfarokhi, M. (2016). Examining Gabriel Tarde's theory of the influence of imitation on social behavior. Proceedings of the First National Conference on Fiqh, Law, and Psychology, Shiraz. {in persian}
Jamali, M. (2025). Examining Gabriel Tarde's theory of the influence of imitation on social behavior. Civilica. {in persian}
Jahan-e Sanat. (2025). Poverty, unemployment, and the rise of theft in Iran. Jahan-e Sanat Newspaper. {in persian}
Hosseinbar, R., & Hosseinbar, H. (2022). A closer look at delinquency (Causes and prevention). Proceedings of the Eighth National Scientific Conference on the Development and Promotion of Educational Sciences and Psychology in Iran, Tehran. {in persian}
Khooshkhabar. (2025, December 23). The wounds of poverty and crime on the lives of people destined for marginalization. Khooshkhabar. {in persian}
Shati Talab, Z., & Hojjati Kermani, F. (2008). Poverty and social capital in rural society. Social Welfare Quarterly, 7(28). {in persian}
Shafiei, M. S., & Shafiei, S. (2016). A pathological and preventive analysis of juvenile delinquency. In Proceedings of the Second National Conference on Human Sciences. Iran. {in persian}
Taherikia, H. (2014). Gabriel Tarde, social change, and ideology. Iranian Journal of Sociology, 15(4). {in persian}
Fazli, M., & Darabipanah, S. (2016). An analysis of the effects of imprisonment on female prisoners in light of Gabriel Tarde's theory of the "laws of imitation." Criminal Law and Criminology Research, 7(Spring–Summer). {in persian}
Karami, A. A., Shadmanfar, M., & Kargari, N. (2024). The social approach in Iran's criminal policymaking after the Islamic Revolution based on Gabriel Tarde's model. Approach to the Islamic Revolution, 18(69), 255–280. {in persian}
Motavallizadeh Naeini, N. (2020). The criminological theory of imitation and Islamic teachings. Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Religious Studies and Humanities in the Islamic World, Tehran. {in persian}
Maddah, M. (2011). An analysis of the relationship between income inequality and crime rates in Iran. Economic Studies and Policies, 7(1), 75–90. {in persian}
Nasiri, P., Nasiri, A., & Nasiri, V. (2023). Analysis of life security and crime in inefficient urban fabrics in Parsabad. Geography and Human Relations, 14(5), 451–516. {in persian}
Nouraei, S., & Dalaki, T. (2025). The impact of poverty and social inequalities on crime and social crises. Proceedings of the Eighteenth National Conference on New Research in Education, Psychology, Fiqh, Law, and Social Sciences, Shirvan. {in persian}
Vazifehdan, S. (2021). A criminological analysis of imprisonment under Gabriel Tarde's theory of teaching and learning (Case study: Prisoners in Mashhad). In Proceedings of the Third International Conference on the Development and Promotion of Humanities and Management in Society. Iran. {in persian}
Barnes, H. E. (1919). The philosophy of the state in the writings of Gabriel Tarde. The Philosophical Review, 28(3), 248–279.
Barry, A., & Thrift, N. (2007). Gabriel Tarde: Imitation, invention and economy. Economy and Society, 36(4), 509–525.
Borch, C. (2005). Urban imitations: Tarde's sociology revisited. Theory, Culture & Society, 22(3), 81–100.
Brighenti, A. M. (2010). Tarde, Canetti, and Deleuze on crowds and packs. Journal of Classical Sociology, 10(4), 291–314.
Cerulo, M. (2021). Gabriel Tarde. In The Emotions in the Classics of Sociology (pp. 39–53). Routledge.
Gardhouse, A. K. (2025). Gabriel Tarde and the relational foundations of agency (Doctoral dissertation).
King, A. (2016). Gabriel Tarde and contemporary social theory. Sociological Theory, 34(1), 45–61.
Marrero-Guillamón, I. (2013). Actor-network theory, Gabriel Tarde and the study of an urban social movement: The case of Can Ricart, Barcelona. Qualitative Sociology, 36, 403–421.
Nachtomy, O. (2007). Possibility, agency, and individuality in Leibniz's metaphysics. Springer.
Niezen, R. (2014). Gabriel Tarde's publics. History of the Human Sciences, 27(2), 41–59.
Papliloud, C. (2004). Understanding interactivity with Gabriel Tarde. Distinktion, 9, 83–102.
Renneville, M. (2018). Gabriel Tarde, the swallow of French criminology. In The Anthem Companion to Gabriel Tarde (pp. 103–118). Anthem Press.
Tarde, G. (1903). The laws of imitation (E. C. Parsons, Trans.). The Mershon Company.
Tarde, G. (2000). Social laws: An outline of sociology (H. C. Warren, Trans.). Batoche Books.
Tarde, G. (2012). Monadology and sociology (T. Lorenc, Ed. & Trans.). Re-Press.
Tonkonoff, S. (2014). Crime as social excess: Reconstructing Gabriel Tarde's criminal sociology. History of the Human Sciences, 27(2), 60–74.
United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2021). Global study on homicide 2021. UNODC.
Walker Jr., B. D. (2022). Evaluating the concepts of the Tarde imitation theory and its impact on training effectiveness for law enforcement in times of disaster.