The Islamic Revolution Approach

The Islamic Revolution Approach

Identity pluralism and political-social tensions in Iran after the reform period

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD student of Political Sociology, Faculty of Law, Theology and Political Sciences, Science and Research Unit, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2 Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Political Science, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
3 Associate Professor, Department of Political Science and Islamic Revolution Studies, Faculty of Humanities, Shahid University, Tehran, Iran
4 Professor of Political Science/Political Thought and Iranian Issues, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Numerous studies have been conducted on movements and socio-political unrest, examining them from multiple perspectives. In Iran, many studies have focused on social transformations, often identifying identity as one of the causes of such changes. The central question of this article is the relationship between identity pluralism and political and social tensions in Iran, with a focus on the period after the reform era. The hypothesis suggests that identity in Iran today is not monolithic, given that it has manifested at subnational, national, and transnational levels, and that identity has become fragmented, globalized, and virtualized. As a result, during social tensions, each dimension of identity can align with or be influenced by competing ideologies or discourses. The findings of this study reveal that in various instances of social unrest, one or more aspects of existing identities become activated, playing a pivotal role in driving tensions. The study adopts a discourse analysis approach, with data collection conducted through library research.
Introduction
One of the most significant elements that distinguishes humans from other beings is the issue of identity. Sociologists consider identity to be a defining characteristic for understanding individuals. One of the critical discussions surrounding identity is its relationship with social movements. Social unrest, which often arises from economic and political tensions, can be analyzed through the lens of social identities, especially the multiplicity of these identities. Investigating the plurality of identities within social movements can lead to a better understanding of such movements. Therefore, this study focuses on the central question of how the pluralism of social identities has influenced tensions and social unrest in Iran after the reform era.
Methodology
Although every society may appear to form a single unified entity, it is made up of individual members, each with their distinct identity. Identity is essential for individuals living within a society, and it can be considered one of the most fundamental human needs in the social dimension. Typically, societies consist of multiple identities that coexist and together form a higher-level identity, which is the national identity. Identities can be influenced by various sources, including political (political-ideological orientations, parties, interest groups, unions, civil institutions, etc.), religious (religious or mystical groups), gender, linguistic (subnational and local languages and dialects), or ethnic (ethnic or racial minorities). These elements collectively form an individual's primary identity. In contemporary Iran, citizens draw their identity from both synchronic (contemporaneous) and diachronic (historical) sources. Language, religion, mythology, and historical consciousness are diachronic identity sources, while modern and globalized values and norms constitute synchronic identity sources. Together, these elements create the plural identity of contemporary Iranian citizens.
Findings
Based on the definitions of identity and the analytical levels of subnational, national, and transnational, the impact of identity on social unrest in Iran can be analyzed on three levels: 1) ethnic identity and political and social unrest; 2) national identity and political tensions; 3) transnational identity and socio-political unrest. At each of these levels, one or more identity sources have contributed to the stimulation of social movements.
Conclusion
Regarding the tensions and unrest in Iran after the reform era, one of the less analyzed factors is the relationship between identity and social movements. This research examines the connection between identity and socio-political tensions on three levels: subnational (ethnic), national, and transnational (global). Several examples of tensions and unrest occurring within Iran’s borders were analyzed. The findings indicate that some of the tensions and unrest during this period had identity-related origins, which must be considered in any analysis and interpretation. Today, identity is one of the most significant drivers of new social movements.
Keywords

  • Al-Taee, Ali (2017). "The Crisis of Ethnic Identity in Iran." Tehran, Shadgan Publications.
  • Ashraf Nazari, Ali (2007). "Modern Identity and the Emergence of Constitutional Discourse in Iran." Quarterly Journal of National Studies, Vol. 8, No. 4, p. 1.
  • Astiri, Majid (2017). "Examining the Impact of Social Media Usage on Social Identity." Motivation and Lifestyle Journal, Summer 2017, No. 3.

 

  • Bashiriyeh, Hossein (2009). "Interview with Logos Magazine," published on internet websites.
  • Beck, Colin J. (2019). Radicals, Revolutionaries, Terrorists, translated by Iraj Hemmati and Mohammad Babaei, Qom, Logos Publishing.
  • Bourdieu, Pierre (2014). Distinction, translated by Hassan Chavoshian, Tehran, Talaye Publications.
  • Castells, Manuel (2001). The Information Age: Economy, Society, and Culture (The Rise of the Network Society), translated by Ahmad Ali Gholian and Afshin Khakbaz, Tehran, Tarh-e-No Publications.
  • Derenik, Jean-Pierre (1989). The Middle East in the Twentieth Century, translated by Farangis Ardalan, Tehran, Badregheh Javidan Publications.
  • Durkundi, Lefteh, Taheri Khonakdari, Mohammad, and Pour Akhound, Nader (2022). "A Critical Examination of the Ethnic Policies of the Pahlavi Governments (1979-1925)." Pathways of the Islamic Revolution, 16(59), 129-148.
  • Eslahchi, Morteza (2008). "Unpredictability: Political Action of Iranians." Monthly Report, September 2008, No. 200.
  • Ghorbi, Seyyed Mohammad Javad; Heydari, Mansour (2017). "The Role of Solidarity in Strengthening the Inner Structure of National Power in the Islamic Republic of Iran." Quarterly Journal of Defense Policy, Vol. 25, No. 98, Spring 2017.
  • Giddens, Anthony (1999). Modernity and Self-Identity, translated by Nasir Mofaghian, Tehran, Ney Publishing.
  • Hajiani, Ebrahim (2000). "A Sociological Analysis of National Identity in Iran and Proposal of Several Hypotheses." Quarterly Journal of National Studies, Vol. 2, No. 5.
  • Hajiani, Ebrahim (2018). "Protests and Unrest of December 2017 (Analysis and Estimates)." Tehran, Research Institute for Strategic Studies Publications.
  • Jenkins, Richard (2002). Social Identity, translated by Touraj Yarahmadi, Tehran, Shirazeh Publications.
  • Kalantar Mehrjardi, Alireza, and Khormashad, Mohammad Baqer (2017). "Political Discourse and the Issue of National Identity Before the Islamic Revolution." Pathways of the Islamic Revolution, 11(41), 71-96.
  • Kaosi, Ismail and Heyzadeh Zohreh (2011). "Preserving Iranian-Islamic Identity in the Process of Globalization." Strategic Studies of Public Policy, 2(3), 37-62.
  • Kermani Fard, Hossein (2016). "Examining the Cohesion and Identity-Value Solidarity of the Ruling Elite in Iran (1979-2013)." Journal of the Islamic Revolution Research, 6(21), 1-22. doi: 10.22084/rjir.2017.1777
  • Maghsoudi, Mojtaba and Simin Hajipour Sardouei (2013). "Human as the Central Signifier in the Discourse of Moderation: A Study of the Governmental Model of Ali (PBUH)." Quarterly Journal of Political and International Studies, Vol. 5, No. 35, Autumn.
  • Mirbagheri, Seyyed Mohammad Mehdi (2010). Cultural Anatomy of the 2009 Sedition, Tehran, Fajr Velayat Publications.
  • Niakoui, Amir (2014). "Sociology of Political Conflicts in Iran: The 2009 Election." Journal of Political Science Research, 10(1), 199-230.
  • Phillips, Louise; Jørgensen, Marianne (2010). Theory and Method in Discourse Analysis, translated by Hadi Jalili, Tehran, Ney Publishing.
  • Poostinchi, Zahra, and Pazan, Mojgan (2013). "Crisis Management Patterns in Light of Identity Fault Lines in the Middle East." Global Politics, 2(4), 133-159.
  • Rastgar, Yasser, and Rabani, Ali (2013). "An Analysis of National Identity Status and Its Six Dimensions Among Citizens of Isfahan." Applied Sociology, 24(2), 1-20.
  • Rouhi, Nabi Allah (2005). "People-Centric Security in Crisis Management: A Case Study of Kurdistan." Quarterly Journal of Defense Policy, Fall and Winter 2005, Nos. 52 and 53.
  • Shayegan, Dariush (2009). New Enchantment: Fragmented Identity and Nomadic Thought, translated by Fatemeh Valiani, Tehran, Farzan Roos Publications.
  • Torki, Hossein (2020). "Examining Political and Economic Factors Affecting Ethnic Challenges (Iranian Kurds)." Specialized Quarterly of Political Science, 16(50), 1-20.