The Islamic Revolution Approach

The Islamic Revolution Approach

The Impact of Cryptocurrencies on Decision-Making Processes and the Legal Requirements for Criminalizing Fraud and Forgery in This Context

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD student, Department of Law, Bushehr Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bushehr, Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Bushehr Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bushehr, Iran
Abstract
The emergence of cryptocurrency based on distributed ledger technology has led to significant changes in electronic commerce, as well as monetary and banking systems, reducing costs and increasing the speed of value transfers. At the same time, these cryptocurrencies, with features such as user anonymity, decentralization, and irreversibility of transactions, have created opportunities for crimes such as money laundering, fraud, and forgery. This research, using a descriptive-analytical approach, examines the legal challenges related to cryptocurrency crimes and explores solutions for controlling them. The findings show that legal gaps and the lack of a precise legal definition of cryptocurrencies have created challenges in judicial proceedings. Among the proposed solutions are the amendment of existing laws, the enactment of new laws that are in line with the characteristics of cryptocurrencies, and the enhancement of international cooperation. Additionally, training and empowering judges and law enforcement officers, as well as fostering collaboration between government and private sectors, have been proposed as strategies to address these challenges. These measures can help control criminal activities related to cryptocurrencies and strengthen the criminal justice system in combating this emerging phenomenon.
Introduction
Cryptocurrencies represent a significant innovation in modern technology, offering dramatic changes to the financial and banking industries through distributed ledger technology. This system enables fast and cost-effective value transfer, presenting both opportunities and challenges. The dual nature of cryptocurrencies facilitates efficient transactions while also allowing potential misuse in criminal activities such as money laundering and fraud.
Main Body
The research primarily addresses the legal intricacies and challenges posed by the criminal use of cryptocurrencies. With their rise, traditional legal frameworks find themselves under-equipped to handle the unique aspects of digital currency, such as the lack of a central regulatory authority and the anonymity of transactions. This creates a fertile ground for financial crimes, necessitating a reevaluation of current legal definitions and regulatory measures.
The study explores various international approaches to cryptocurrency regulation, highlighting the disparities in legal frameworks across different jurisdictions. It emphasizes the need for a cohesive legal definition that encompasses the broad spectrum of digital currencies, from decentralized cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin to potential central bank digital currencies. The research advocates for comprehensive legislation that clearly defines cryptocurrencies' legal status, accompanied by appropriate regulatory and enforcement mechanisms.
Key challenges identified include the difficulty in tracing cryptocurrency transactions due to their anonymous nature, the lack of a centralized monitoring system, and the potential for cryptocurrencies to be used in cross-border crimes, complicating jurisdictional and legal enforcement. The paper suggests that improving legal frameworks could involve defining cryptocurrencies within national legal systems, enhancing the capabilities of law enforcement agencies to monitor and control these digital assets, and fostering international cooperation to tackle cross-border cryptocurrency crimes effectively.
Conclusion
The paper concludes that to mitigate the risks associated with crypto currencies while harnessing their potential benefits, significant legal reforms are necessary. These reforms should aim to close existing legal loopholes that facilitate crypto currency-related crimes and develop a clear and comprehensive legal framework that addresses the unique characteristics of digital currencies. Additionally, international collaboration and consistent legal standards across borders will be crucial in managing the global nature of crypto currencies and ensuring a secure digital financial environment. Through detailed analysis and proposed legal reforms, the study contributes to a deeper understanding of the necessary adjustments within the legal and regulatory frameworks to safeguard against the misuse of crypto currencies while promoting their legitimate use in the global economy.
Keywords

Center for Strategic Research of the Islamic Parliament. (2018). Virtual currencies: Legislation in various countries and proposals for Iran. September 2018.
Ahmadian, H., & Dehghani, R. (2015). The views and thoughts of Ulrich Beck (the theorist of the risk society). Social Development Quarterly, 10(2), Winter 2015.
Boromand, Sh., & colleagues. (2008). Economic security in Iran and selected countries (comparative study). Tehran: Economic Studies, Center for Strategic Research, Islamic Parliament.
Beck, U. (2009). World risk society (trans. M. M. Zadeh). Tehran: Kavir {in Persian}.
Pak-Nahad, A. Risk-oriented criminal policy. Tehran: Mizan {in Persian}.
Pradel, J. (2020). History of criminal thought (trans. A. H. Najafi Abrand Abadi), 11th ed. Tehran: Samt {in Persian}.
Khalili Pachi, A. (2019). Feasibility of terrorism financing in the light of cryptocurrency. In: Proceedings of the International Conference on Legal and Criminological Dimensions of Terrorism, Tehran: Allameh Tabatabai University. {in Persian}
Delmas-Marty, M. (2019). Major criminal political systems (trans. A. H. Najafi Abrand Abadi), 2nd ed. Tehran: Mizan {in Persian}.
Rahberpour, M. (2014). The jurisprudential bases of prohibition and criminalization in the realm of biotic ethics. Islamic Law Quarterly, 11(42), Fall 2014 {in Persian}.
Siyahbidi Kermanshahi, S., & others. (2018). Economic criminal law. Tehran: Javdaneh {in Persian}.
Siyahbidi Kermanshahi, S., & others. (2019). Commentary on the law on combating the smuggling of goods and currency. Tehran: Javdaneh {in Persian}.
Siyahbidi Kermanshahi, S., & A. A. Tahlis Moyeid. (2017). Economic criminal law, money laundering. Tehran: Mizan {in Persian}.
Shamloo, B., & A. Khalili Pachi. (2019). The virtual rise of white-collar crime in the light of cryptocurrencies. Justice Legal Journal, 84(110), Summer 2019 {in Persian}.
Shahideh, F., & A. H. Niazpour. (2019). Proactive criminalization of terrorist acts. Criminal Law Teachings, 17(19), Spring and Summer 2019 {in Persian}.
Saqal, Y. (2018). A legal and criminological study of crime in the world risk society (PhD dissertation in criminal law and criminology). Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, 2018 {in Persian}.
Farahbakhsh, M. (2010). The impact of utilitarianism on criminalization. PhD dissertation in criminal law and criminology, University of Tehran {in Persian}.
Laurent Chiten, P., & colleagues. (2013). Anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism: A practical guide for banking regulators (trans. M. Keshtkar). Tehran: Tash {in Persian}.
Mahmoudi Janki, F., & M. Roustaei. (2013). Justification of criminal intervention, principles and necessities. Criminal Law Research, 2(3), Spring and Summer 2013 {in Persian}.
Mir-Mohammad-Sadeghi, H., & Z. Laki. (2019). A new approach to criminal referral in light of the principle of fair labelling. Criminal Law Research, 7(27), Summer 2019 {in Persian}.
Mir-Mohammad-Sadeghi, H., & A. Rahmati. (2014). Examples of deviation from the general principles of criminal law in crimes against security. Strategy Quarterly, 24(76), Fall 2014 {in Persian}.
Najafi Abrand Abadi, A. H. (2016). Legal criminology (an introduction to public criminal law criminology). In: New Criminal Science, Volume 2, edited by A. H. Najafi Abrand Abadi, 2nd ed. Tehran: Mizan {in Persian}.
Nowab Poor, A. (2018). A jurisprudential analysis of the functions of encrypted money (case study: Bitcoin). University of Tehran, Faculty of Political Science {in Persian}.
Same author. (2012). On security studies (from the right to security to the right to provision). Preface in: Rezvani, S., Human-Centered Risk Management of Crime. Tehran: Mizan {in Persian}.
Same author. (2009). New penology – new criminology: An introduction to managerial risk-oriented criminal policy. In: New Criminal Science, Volume 1, edited by A. H. Najafi Abrand Abadi, Tehran: Mizan {in Persian}.
Najafi Abrand Abadi, A. H., M. J. Habibzadeh, & M. A. Babaei. (2004). Preventive crimes (deterrent crimes). Humanities School Journal, 37, Winter 2004 {in Persian}.